Akhundzada: Everyone in Afghanistan Must Be Hanafi

At a gathering at Kabul University, Taliban leader Hibatullah Akhundzada claimed all people of Afghanistan follow the Hanafi school and called the Shafi’i school impermissible, ignoring the country’s religious diversity.

Taliban leader Hibatullah Akhundzada, speaking at Kabul University, claimed that all people of Afghanistan follow the Hanafi school of Islamic jurisprudence and described practising the Shafi’i school as impermissible, a claim that ignores the country’s religious diversity.

The gathering, titled “A Scholarly and Research Review of the Consequences of the Taliban Leader’s Decrees”, opened at Kabul University on Monday, 16 November, and continued on Tuesday. It was organised by the Taliban’s Ministry of Higher Education and attended by a number of the group’s senior officials, religious scholars and university lecturers.

A speech without pictures: how the Taliban leader’s voice was released

One notable feature of the gathering was the tight restriction on information about Akhundzada’s presence. Local sources reported that photography and filming at the event were banned, and Taliban-affiliated media refrained from publishing any new photos or video of the meeting.

Audio files of the participants’ speeches were nevertheless released, and Akhundzada’s voice also became available through an audio recording. So despite the ban on images, his voice reached audiences; but at the time of writing, no footage of his presence or speech at the event had been made public.

Local sources also say Akhundzada has prevented the release of his photos and videos in previous years as well. This approach continues even as, in his position as Taliban leader, he makes decisions about the lives of millions of Afghanistan’s citizens, while his public appearances and the media’s ability to question him directly remain extremely limited.

This way of handling information raises questions about transparency and accountability: why is a gathering its organisers describe as scholarly and research-based denied visual recording and free media coverage? If the goal is a scholarly review of the decrees, why are the public and the media unable to observe that review directly?

A call to love the leader: obedience instead of public consent

In his speech, Akhundzada asked those present to encourage people to love the Taliban leader so that they would follow his decrees. He also said that implementing Sharia rulings creates unity and harmony among Muslims, and stressed that he would not set Muslims against one another to preserve his power.

But these remarks leave a fundamental question unanswered: through what mechanism can people freely express their views about the leader, his decrees and his policies? Love for a leader cannot be created by official request and propaganda, nor can it replace public consent, political participation and citizens’ right to choose.

In systems grounded in human rights, political legitimacy is not measured by the degree of forced obedience; it depends on the free consent of the people, the ability to criticise power, credible elections, freedom of expression and the accountability of officials. Under the Taliban’s structure, the people of Afghanistan have no role in choosing the group’s leader or setting its major policies, and free political competition is not possible.

The claim of an Islamic system and the reality of women’s exclusion

Akhundzada spoke of establishing what he calls an “Islamic system” and justified the enforcement of his decrees within the Taliban’s interpretation of Sharia. At the same gathering, Abdul Hakim Sharaee, the Taliban’s justice minister, called the Quran the group’s constitution and described man-made laws as contrary to Sharia.

But labelling a political structure an Islamic system does not, on its own, prove its justice, its respect for human dignity or its legitimacy. Any system must be judged not only by the religious and political claims of its leaders but by how it treats people, how far it respects fundamental rights, and whether citizens can seek justice and take part in public life.

The reality on the ground in Afghanistan is far from the claims of justice and human dignity. Girls are barred from education beyond grade six, women are banned from entering universities, and sweeping restrictions are imposed on their work, movement and presence in public life.

According to UNESCO, about 2.4 million girls in Afghanistan have been deprived of secondary education. The United Nations has also stressed that Afghanistan is the only country in the world where women and girls are formally barred from secondary and higher education.

In such circumstances, insisting on the enforcement of decrees without accountability for their consequences cannot take the place of justice. If the aim is justice, how can depriving half of society of education, work and public participation be reconciled with human equality and the dignity of citizens?

Claimed unity and the exclusion of political opponents

At the gathering, Abdul Hakim Haqqani, the Taliban’s chief justice, said the group accepts interference from no one. He also defended the Taliban’s rise to power without any agreement with other political movements, and claimed that the participation of former officials in the power structure could have weakened the Taliban.

These remarks point less to national unity than to the Taliban’s monopolistic view of power. Unity in a diverse society is not achieved by eliminating differing views; it requires accepting ethnic, religious, linguistic and political diversity, freedom for political parties to operate, and the genuine participation of all groups in society.

Since returning to power in August 2021, the Taliban have kept the political structure under their exclusive control. Opposition movements, independent representatives and social groups outside this structure have no share in major decisions. A claim of unity that does not accept the right to dissent and equal participation means enforced uniformity more than social solidarity.

The claim that there is no religious or linguistic discrimination

Taliban officials at the meeting also claimed there are no religious or linguistic divisions among the group’s members. But the absence of disagreement within a political group does not mean the absence of discrimination across society.

Afghanistan’s society is made up of many ethnic groups, languages and religious traditions, and citizens’ rights must be guaranteed regardless of their ethnicity, religion, language or gender. The measure of equality is not what leaders say about behaviour inside their own group, but the real situation of all citizens, especially groups that have no representation in the structure of power.

Akhundzada: everyone in Afghanistan must be Hanafi

In a speech of about 90 minutes at Kabul University, Hibatullah Akhundzada claimed that all people of Afghanistan follow the Hanafi school. He said “the imam chooses the path” and that, on this basis, everyone must follow Hanafi jurisprudence; he also described practising the Shafi’i school as “impermissible” and called for people to unite on a single path of jurisprudence. These remarks appear in the audio recording of the speech released by Taliban-affiliated media and have been reported by several independent outlets.

The claim that everyone in Afghanistan is Hanafi does not match the country’s demographic reality. Although most Muslims in Afghanistan are Sunni and follow Hanafi jurisprudence, Shia citizens, including followers of the Jafari and Ismaili schools, form an important part of society. In addition, there are followers of Shafi’i jurisprudence among Afghanistan’s Sunnis.

The US State Department’s 2023 International Religious Freedom Report, citing varying estimates, puts the Shia share of the population at about 11 to 29 percent. The European Union’s 2024 country guidance estimates it at about 10 to 15 percent. The figures differ because there has been no accurate religious census, but both sources confirm the existence of a large Shia community in Afghanistan and refute the claim of “all the people”.

This is not merely a statistical error. From his position as Taliban leader, Akhundzada has prescribed one school of thought for the entire population and declared the practice of another impermissible. Such a stance disregards the religious diversity of society and raises concern that followers of other schools will face greater restrictions on their religious rights and freedoms.

Freedom of religion and belief includes the right to hold or change one’s beliefs, to practise religious rituals and to belong to a school of jurisprudence. No political authority can determine the religious identity of all citizens simply by declaring a single path. Social unity does not mean the forced uniformity of beliefs; it gains meaning by recognising differences and guaranteeing equal rights for followers of different faiths.

Taken together with reports of restrictions on Shia religious institutions and pressure on some religious communities, these remarks deepen concerns about the state of religious freedom in Afghanistan. The test of any claim to unity is not the imposition of a single jurisprudential reading, but guaranteeing the security and freedom of all citizens, whatever their faith or belief.

“The world’s only Islamic system”: a claim without clear criteria

Khairullah Khairkhwa, the Taliban’s governor of Maidan Wardak, claimed at the gathering that Afghanistan is the only country in the world with an “Islamic system”. He also said efforts must be made to overcome challenges that could cause problems for this system.

Without a clear definition of what makes a system Islamic, and without examining the state of citizens’ rights and freedoms, this claim is more a propaganda position than the result of any scholarly assessment. The Islamic world includes many countries with different political structures, and no agreed standard has been offered to support the Taliban’s claim to exclusivity.

More important than competing over titles is the state of people’s lives. Poverty, unemployment, restrictions on education, the exclusion of women from work and the absence of civil liberties are realities that do not disappear by declaring a religious title.

A scholarly conference, or a gathering to endorse decrees?

The Taliban presented the meeting as scholarly and research-based, and announced that hundreds of papers had been prepared on the group leader’s decrees. However, local sources report that questionnaires were distributed among a number of university lecturers about granting Akhundzada the title of “Sheikh al-Islam”.

Participating lecturers were reportedly required to record their names and positions alongside their views on the proposal. Some said this put them in a difficult position, because opposing a proposal about the Taliban leader could have consequences for them. It is still unclear what role these questionnaires played in the final decision, or whether the title has been formally granted to Akhundzada.

For this reason, the granting of the title “Sheikh al-Islam” cannot be considered confirmed. What has been reported is the proposal and the collection of some participants’ views, not the documented announcement of an independent and transparent process for choosing or granting the title.

Meanwhile, the week-long closure of Kabul University and the clearing of student dormitories to host the meeting raise another question about the Taliban’s priorities. A university should be a space for teaching, research and free debate, not a place from which students are pushed out so that a gathering to endorse the Taliban leader’s decrees can be held.

The real test of the claims is people’s rights

Akhundzada’s speech and the remarks of Taliban officials at Kabul University put forward a series of claims about unity, justice, Sharia and public consent; but none of these concepts can be judged apart from the reality of citizens’ lives.

Unity has meaning when political opponents have the right to be present; justice is achieved when women and men enjoy equal rights; education is valuable when the doors of universities and schools are open to all; and public consent can be measured only when people can voice dissent without fear of arrest and punishment.

The hiding of the Taliban leader’s image, alongside the selective release of his voice, is also a symbol of the gap between a claim to authority and accountability. A leader who demands obedience from the people must be answerable to them and for the consequences of his decisions. Holding costly meetings and gathering like-minded officials cannot replace the free participation of the people and respect for their fundamental rights.

This report was first published in Persian by Shana News Agency: read the original.

📢 وقتی صدای افغانستان خاموش شود، تاریخ خاموش می‌ماند…

خبرگزاری شانا؛ صدای افغانستان

ما را دنبال کنید:

هم‌رسانی این خبر: تلگرام واتس‌اپ فیسبوک ایکس
این مطلب را می‌پسندید؟ با پسند شما در «انتخاب مخاطبان» دیده می‌شود.
خبرها را زودتر از همه در تلگرام بخوانیدکانال رسمی خبرگزاری شانا؛ خبر فوری، گزارش و روایت مردمعضویت در کانال